Dave must have gotten a really good slice, cause his rating is way too high. The only thing truly New York about this pizza is the size of it; each slice is HUGE, with massive NYC flop. But there is no crisp at all on this pie, it feels like it’s very undercooked. Super soft dough, extra cheesy and an extremely doughy crust, all lacking in overall taste. The sauce is completely indistinguishable; not to mention the oil slick gushing from the butter fat in the cheese. This is a dollar slice pie masquerading as a $20 Brooklyn pizza. A totally forgettable New York pie; nothing to see here.
