Good Guys Pizza

A pizza lover’s pizza! Lots of crust and cheese and a tasty sauce. One of Buffalo’s best pizzas! It’s even good when reheated.

Good New York style pizza crust was a little floppy but I forgot to ask for it crispy. Still tasted good!

Very thick and heavy pizza that next skimps on toppings! I easily in my top five for pizzas. I ask for light sauce other than that it’s damn near perfect

I’ve never gone back and changed a score but I am today. I must have caught them on an off day last time or a really good day this time. The sauce is sweet, the dough is soft and chewy, the cheese is piled on and the crust is soft but still has a crisp. This is really good pizza.

This is the next morning lol. Only slice left after my girlfriend and i ate the whole thing on our yacht so good amazing sauce tons of cheese

I like the sauce, but thick cheese and soft pizza makes it just so-so!

My hometown pie I’m trying to rate fairly. No flop- thick cheese- with a nice light fluffy crust. Always a knock out with a nice sweet sauce and again- their thick cheese layer.

So much cheese .. very very good

Cheesey. Good sauce. Crispy crust.

Best Pizza in town hands down. Great sauce! Lots of cheese.

Always a bit soupy but the flavor is a winner. Ordered well-done but the crust has crisp regardless. Cheese is a standard blend and sauce is unique to this spot. Worth a stop for a slice!

This is their NY style. Very Crispy crust, great ingredients. No flop

This was a little undercooked but I loved the crust. Distinct sauce and very cheesy.

Large New York style. Greatest pizza in the buffalo area in my opinion.

Decent pizza. Good sauce. Average size buffalo style crust. Big complaint is wayyy to much cheese. Needs about half. Worth it for a one time but not going back.

Not enough sauce good dough crust is good needs more flavor

Great sauce! Great crust! And a lot of cheese!!

Big flop, very doughy, cheese doesn't really stay on the slice when u bite it, sauce is amazing and good crust

This pizza is the absolute best pie in all of WNY the crust to cheese to sauce to pepperoni ratio is perfectly paired. Excellent choice of spices to create one of the most amazing experiences of your life the pizza will bring back the little things from your childhood.

This pizza has consistency of ale house loaded cheese and pepperoni but pepperoni different!! Crust is good and this place is basically the old pizza junction!!