Goodfella's Pizza Italian Restaurant (Matamoras)

Solid pizza, no flop, and a solid price.

Amazing pizza! super light! super crispy, a bit of a wait but its because its made to order. But entirely worth the wait i strongly recommend grandmas pie its a thin crust with fresh Mozzarella and thin sliced tomato. I personally dont like warm tomato but whatever they are doing is magic. lets give this place some love and get dave here.

6 dollar slices. Huge but a little pricey. CBR was solid but margarita could use some help. Floppy no crunch. Crust gave a little bump.

You gotta be brain dead if your coming here to get pizza. Id rather chew on a piece of cardboard.

Too thick and doughy through the entire pizza. Floppy with no crunch. I ordered a Medium so that I could have some extra for lunch the next day; turns out the medium is more like an extra large size. It’s ridiculous. Also the slices are extreme. I could only eat 2. Couldn’t even fit the slice into my lunch bag the next day. Needs improvement. Nearly ruined pizza for me.

Monster size slice! Undercooked and chewy some flop! Overall bland and boring.

I looked at this pizza thinking how I don’t know about this place. Nobody ever said a word. Looks amazing! The worst pizza I have ever ingested. Now I know. Joeys in Milford or nothing around here!

Good flavor! A little flip flop to it. Fair value slice.

Very huge slice. Thick crust. Too much cheese.

Thatsa Huge Slice! Crust is only lightly cooked, it’s tasty and super thin with full floppiness. Sauce and cheese are just of average quality. Once you get by the novelty of the size, the slice is good but not outstanding.

Amazing crust, not a lot of flop, not a lot a grease, could have used more sauce. Good pie

How you doing with this huge slice. Not for nothing, not a bad slice

Average. Not great. Nice people though.

Great big slice of pizza with great sauce and the right amount of cheese.