Good football pizza thats affordable for the area, but overall that’s it. Decent crust, not a lot of flavor, medium greasy and flop...which doesn’t really bother me. Just average at best, but a step up from the chain restaurants. Manager/Owner was super cool and place is clean. If you brought this to a game, no one would complain, but don’t expect compliments either. That’s a review.
Order now on Slice
Order Goodfella's Pizza
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
bino4/30/21, 12:38 a.m.
Decent slice, nice crisp, a little cheesy a little grease but good football pizza
greg.trant1/19/21, 3:38 p.m.
People in Florida have no clue what good pizza is. That is why good pizza in Florida is super rare. Before the new owners took over and called it Goodfellas Pizza this used to be Jupiter pizza and it made a really good pizza. Based on pizza ALONE, not customer service or anything else. maybe 3.1 on their best day. Jupiter Pizza before them, 7.5
ron.capute12/21/20, 12:11 a.m.
This was an interesting pie because the more I ate, the better it got. At first the crust was very floppy and the whole thing was lacking flavor. It then seemed to tighten up when it cooled a bit. So others mentioned that this is a somewhat greasy pizza, which is true, but I kinda like it that way. Once it cooled the crust had better bite and the flavor of the sauce really came through. I give it a 7.8 but that is in relative terms. This is south Florida don't expect to find anything over an 8.
gabeguidetti11/21/20, 10:16 p.m.
Ok so we have a guest review with donia today (she got the plain slice) and went with an 8.3.... the grandma slice seems to be in the same area possibly an 8.2.... only flaw was we picked some slices that have been out for a while so we didnt get the full fresh appeal but nonetheless definitely some of the best pizza around south florida
nick.vollaro8/2/20, 10:26 p.m.
Wasnt overly impressed by the look of it but the overall score is right on here. Cheese and sauce were very good and crust was amazing.
jessica.kearns3/3/20, 12:08 a.m.
Pretty greasy slice of pizza, good sauce flavor, but not much flavor in the pepperoni, a lot of flop and the crust is decent. Overall this pizza seems overrated
fitz275511/3/19, 10:55 p.m.
Solid pizza.. Good tang on sauce.. a tad greasy but overall very good for Florida
miketherider7/13/19, 6:24 p.m.
Good pie. Little bit of grease, asked for the crust as “well done” and it was pretty spot on. A little excessive flop, but overall a solid pizza. Ordered the regular style. Drove 35 min to try it, would probably do it again. People rating it over 8 are/were figuratively, and likely literally, high.
bobby.light6/27/19, 8:00 p.m.
pro pie, had the grandma, sauce is the showstopper, ingredients are fresh, crust is light but holds up real well, staff is great - wouldn't be shocked if someone said this was the best in south florida - will return next time in west palm
tyler.bendeson6/18/19, 12:24 a.m.
This vegan pizza is awesome, I love the pesto and the mushrooms
32 views•1 like
4cameronclayton5/12/19, 10:32 p.m.
Best pizza in Jupiter by far! Flop is great. Just great overall.
304 views•1 like
joe.b123/29/19, 12:40 a.m.
WOW! This was the best pizza I’ve ever had! I highly recommend the Grandma Pie.
nick.defalco12/26/19, 12:00 a.m.
Really good!! Super excited to have something close to NY pizza local
hannah.a12/16/18, 10:13 p.m.
Great veggie slice, veggies cooked perfectly. Cheesy and delicious.
doug.desantis12/14/18, 2:20 a.m.
I had high hopes, was slightly disappointed. Ok pizza, won’t rave about or tell my kids about it. That’s a review.
richard.white112/13/18, 7:01 p.m.
One bite of the Grandma Sicilian is all you need to say Goodfellas Pizza in Jupiter is hands down the best around. Also had a meatlovers slice! Crispy crust flavorful cheese savory sauce. Customer service is top notch. My only go to from now on!
jake.steiger12/11/18, 4:46 p.m.
A very solid slice, not worthy of an 8....that’s ridiculous. The pizza itself is a 7.4 but the customer service brings it to a 7.7. The dudes back there are friendly and great people to talk to. Stop by if you want a solid slice and a good conversation.