holtznathan8/12/20, 5:38 p.m.
First pizza in the new city and I have to say Frankie I’m a bit surprised. Very solid slice here in the streets of Cincinnati, Ohio. Nothing crazy but solid nonetheless. Cheese to pepperoni to sauce ratio was good. Although the sauce had a bit of a tang to it, it was good. Cheese was a little lacking in flavor but at the same time I don’t want to bite into a slice of cheese when I eat a pizza so there’s that. The best part was definitely the crust. Super thin slice reminded me of the streets of New York. Could’ve been a little crispier but wasn’t underdone or anything. Very good pizza and would come back again for sure.
doughboydrew7/7/19, 5:52 a.m.
Very good pizza. If it wasn’t for the grease it would be high 7’s or low 8’s. Very good thin crust. Sauce is very good. Highly recommend.
54 views•5 likes
chris.gore55/15/19, 9:22 p.m.
For sure got a goofy slice, good flavor but whoever threw the dough left holes in the pie. Disappointed
rollin.dough.reviews4/8/19, 5:58 p.m.
Rollin’ Dough Review: Straight up: this is good pizza. Love the set up with the walk up counter, slices ready to go. Big slice, one is all I needed. I got the special - slice, giant breadstick and a Coke and I was stuffed. The crust was near-perfect, excellent floury lightness yet firm enough body to resist the flop for the most part ,but not too firm. The outer edge had a perfect crisp to it. Good sauce, not too much of anything, just a solid base and some good quality cheese. This pizza was a particular favorite of mine to review as it brought back memories of growing up in NY and eating at the local Italian families spot, Aiello’s Pizzeria. That was real stuff that, even after 25 years, my taste buds haven’t forgotten, and Goodfellas is the closest to their style and taste I’ve found since. This pizza is a solid 8.0 on its own, but that’s a rookie score, and the nostalgia gives it the extra .5 from me. That’s a review.
david.hornback3/15/19, 4:36 p.m.
Decent. Not very saucy, did like how they warmed up the slice before giving it to me. A good option for Cincinnati.
brandon.brydges3/2/19, 8:18 p.m.
Good crust, expected more. Need better flavor on the sauce. Note: great house ranch. Excellent bourbon selection
joebrown4ever2/10/19, 6:38 p.m.
Goodfellas, Cincinnati location in Over The Rhine ... humungous, BIG, super sized ... and it's just a regular large pepperoni ... great price, some flop, taste is great... Going high on this score !!!!