zhunt11/24/18, 3:16 a.m.
Has all the potential to be a good slice but lacks a differentiating flavor or excitement. Sure, not a bad piece but if this is my “slice of New York City” I’m canceling my plane ticket.
chris.cioff10/8/18, 6:26 p.m.
They do a good job with the crust but it’s closer to a DC Jumbo slice than to a Real NY slice. Good for Cincinnati
thepizzaexpeditionist9/27/18, 8:43 p.m.
Goodfellas is a solid New York style pizza. They sell by the slice which is great. That said, in New York it would be pretty mediocre. For Cincinnati, it’s great.
marc.lefebvre9/23/18, 11:55 p.m.
Alright Frankie. Goodfellas in Cincinnati. The OTR location. Good flop after the first bite. Gets points for the size of each slice. Too much crunch for me after coming out of the oven. Needs more sauce. Can’t really go wrong but not phenomenal.
caleb.goodwin9/14/18, 3:53 a.m.
Pep placement is sloppy Big asf Solid sauce to crust ratio Not cheesy enough Sober it’s 7.7 at best
lewismergler9/8/18, 6:29 a.m.
Hey followers, your favorite pizza reviewers are back for the drama with a goodfellas review. And you’re watching Disney Channel.
57 views•5 likes