Goodfellas Pizzeria

Great pizza great sauce great crust

Very good pizza. Nice undercarriage and crisp. A little doughy in some spots (like where the pizza bubbles are) but overall a very solid pizza. Great for after the bar. The pepperoni was super greasy but I don’t think that can be helped because of the pepperoni. Huge slices. The largest pizza has 8 slices but can feed a family of 10. The price for a cheese is super affordable. A must try for sure.

Goodfellas Pizza truly deserves a perfect 10/10 rating. The pizza is a masterpiece of flavors, with a perfect balance of crust crispiness, savory toppings, and a mouthwatering blend of cheeses. Each bite is a journey into pizza perfection, and the quality of ingredients is evident in every slice. The impeccable service and inviting ambiance create a delightful dining experience. Goodfellas Pizza sets the standard for what a top-tier pizzeria should be, making it a must-visit for any pizza enthusiast.

Good ass pizza

Arguably my favorite pizza in Cincy. New York style. One slice is all you need.

Solid NY Style pizza with good undercarriage, nice crunch on the crust, spicy sauce good ratio of cheese to sauce, and the toppings were on point. There was a little too much crust for me which is why I scored it 7.3. Respectable score for a respectable pizza.

Best NY style pizza in NKY by far. Key is to get a whole pie or a slice straight from the oven. Perfect undercarriage, no flop, sauce to cheese ratio on point, always great.

Consistently good across all their locations. This one was a little light on the sauce, big as your face slice, perfect crisp, zero flop.

All around a good pizza that you can’t go wrong with. Great sauces and cheese. Thanks Johnny, Gabagool.

Good crunch good flavor

Solid

Very solid

This is the gold medal slice in Northern KY. Sooo crisp, crust on point, just the right amount of sauce, perfectly cheesed, and they make the dough right in front of you. Travel for this pizza!

Extra crispy pepperoni. The crust is outstanding and the ingredients are fresh. Perfection

Solid football slice for game day! Cheese for me, double pepp for best bud. Bubble for the win.

Solid slices for sale and open late. Crispy crust and good flavor with little to no flop.

David-6.7 Blake-7.2 @barstoolxu & @barstoolnku

You kicked him out...

Overall good slice of pizza. crust was awesome, no flop. sauce tasted good. Lots of cheesy goodness. only a little greasy.

Rookie score