Goodfellas Pizzeria

Light pizza, medium flop, toasted under carriage, bubbles in dough, decent taste, crispy crust

Best place in Indy for a pie. Daughter loves it. I love it. Wish we could get it right now.

Yummy pizza!

Great Pizza!!!! Great quick service

Don’t get the 22 inch... trust me

Good but not great. Too much cheese for my liking. Sauce and crust taste spot on. But I can’t get past the globs of cheese.

Took a trip to Indy and just now getting to review it. Got two slices of cheese and a huge breadstick. Since it was by the slice not sure how long it was sitting but it was still great. The bottom crust still had some crunch to it. Still getting a 7.8.

Alright Frankie, got some major flop when its fresh and hot, little greasy. Cheese is alright, good sauce, good crisp on the crust. I'll go a solid 7.1

Top notch

Best pizza I’ve ever had, the first bite crunch is out of this world. Sauce and cheese match perfectly together and the crust tops it off. It is a little heavy but the box is definitely worth getting the 22”.

Amazing first bite crisp. Crust is packed with flavors and cheese tops off a great pizza. Little heavy, would not recommend the 22 incher.

Love the crust and flavor

Great NYC pizza in Indy

had it long ago, saw that dave gave it a solid review. Not impressed but the crust is phenomenal, does feel like a new york slice but the ingredients didnt stand out wt all