Goodfellas Pizzeria - Distillery

Overall, pretty disappointing. Very greasy, slices are too large for a whole pie, way too much flop, terrible undercarriage, crust pretty thin. Good flavor to redeem the pizza but didn’t live up to the hype. At least nobody told me to go that way

Had a slice of pepperoni and margherita. Favored the latter. Pepperoni was greasy but flavorful. The oven does the undercarriage and crust great justice. Breadsticks good.

The pizza is excellent! The under-carriage is good, really cheesy, also the breadsticks are really good.🍕🍕

D&N

Yep, this is the real deal. I'm glad El Prez came back. Exceptional NY pizza in Kentucky! This is better than Goodfellas in Indy... and that's the best pizza in Indy. I'm giving this double snowman.

Vibe was great. Cheese pizza tasted the best out of the three we got. Good undercarriage, wish it had a tad bit more sauce, dynamite crust and the cheese was nice. Overall, worth it. Be sweet to see it around 8:30 at night in the summer.

Back to basics™️. Couldn’t get a pie of my own so I had to settle for a big slice of cheese. Firm crust after putting it back in the oven for a minute. Good flavor on sauce. Breadstick was really good.

Huge slices a positive, but undercooked, thick and doughy.

Listen Davey boy, I’m not doing a biased review here. Keeping it classy and professional. After all, it’s all about the fresh pies. Thought it was great. Great crust and flavor. The sheer size of slices was a plus. Great atmosphere and service. Will definitely be back!

This place is solid, especially for Kentucky. Sweet environment, that alone makes it worth the trip. Upper 7’s for this one, it’s above average.

Solid crisp and cool environment. Great pizza after having a a few drinks.

Huge Pizza! Great crust, sauce a little bland but very good overall. Great under carriage

Crispy crust, large pepperonis and loved the cheese

What they did to Dave, they deserve this low score

Super cool spot and great atmosphere. Went because of Dave’s famous review but would definitely come back for the pizza and atmosphere. Good solid slice.

Service outie was horrible. Guy that waited on is was a Jerk Confusing on seats and restaurants.I spent 75 dollars there on2 pizzas and one guy ruined it.