Goodfellas Pizzeria - Distillery

Dave had to be drunk or high when he did his review.

Good crust

Decent crust, the garlic sausage in excellent, but cheese is just okay.

Tangy, salty, garlicky Each bite is slightly different for some reason. I had amazing ones and meh ones. Would come back monthly if i could 👍

Bland! Flop beyond belief. Have been going here for years now. Love the atmosphere and bringing my kids. Mainly for crank and boom afterwards. Unfortunately no matter the score they won't improve. They get worse every time we go.

Wasn’t impressed

Breadsticks were better than the pizza. Long wait. High prices. Greasy floppy and not hot.

Amazing spot to relax and eat a pizza Crust was goood overall a solid slice

Some of the best pizza I have had in KY!

New York style, which is my favorite. Great undercarriage and minimal flop, but very greasy. Great environment and esthetic inside. Overall good pizza.

Lots of flop. Not much sauce unfortunately. Cheese didn’t have much flavor. Still good

No flop amazing crunch no sauce though crust good flavor

Solid undercarriage, creative topping choices, wish it was hotter

decent, portnoy overrated it

I’m from Lafayette Indiana our pizza at best is a 5 so this is easily a 7.8

Crust was the best part. Also did a regular cheese and pep. Classic was better, hot take- chicken dosent go on pizza

It was alright. Tasted kind of cheap, like a pizza at a sports game. They also threw out a national pizza review host… disgraceful! 6.1, that’s a review.

Overall, pretty disappointing. Very greasy, slices are too large for a whole pie, way too much flop, terrible undercarriage, crust pretty thin. Good flavor to redeem the pizza but didn’t live up to the hype. At least nobody told me to go that way