Goodfellas Pizzeria

Very disappointed based on Dave’s review of the Indianapolis location of an 8.1. I had high hopes but was very let down. Super flop, crust was very doughy and chewy, almost like rubber. The sauce and cheese was just plain and simply BLAND with little to no flavor and way too much garlic butter or whatever they put on the crust. Drove 25-30 minutes to try it ordered online and was there right on time for pick up. Being on the IU campus I’m sure for the price drunk college kids love it but the only reason it’s above a 4 from me is the place and box it comes in is pretty cool. Is very Papa Johns like pizza. Again very disappointing

Pretty good pizza by the slice, tastes better when you get a full pizza from scratch

Nice and crispy and not too greasy. Side note the breadstick is amazing!

Sweet Sweet

Best pizza in town, dont @ me

Nice taste to sauce and minimal flop. Did burn the shit out my face eating this tho. Overall pretty good

Listen this pizza May be pepperoni and not cheese but I can tel you one thing. This pizza has great crisp, the right amount of tang in their sauce and a solid chewy cheese blend. Many have left low scores and I believe the problem is consistency. Every slice I get from here seems to be different. Still a great slice 8.3. It’s only competitor on Kirkwood is wheel pizza and there is absolutely no comparison.

It's very heavy. The char on the crust is very good. Burned my lower lip. A bit too much cheese. Still above average

Really good the sauce could of been better.

Great crisp! Good cheese. Okay sauce

One bite. Everyone knows the rules. With that said, no flop, good crisp, not too greasy. Definitely will make a great choice after a night at KOK, Nick’s, and Upstairs Pup on Kirkwood Ave.

Here we are at 1 AM on Little 5. I’m not gonna lie right now this hits like a 10, however I’m not irresponsible I will give this pizza a 6.7 because that’s just the kind of mood I’m in.

Best pizza in B-Town

Solid pie. Huge slice, very tasty

Tad greasy, good crisp