Goodfellas Pizzeria - Broad Ripple

Very strong upper 6. Ask for it crispy. Sauce doesnt knock your socks off, but good snap on the crust makes up for it. ½ off mondays.

Could fit right into New York City as a dollar slice with no issue no one bats an eye. Could’ve been cooked better though. Too doughy. But the most classic nyc style pie you can get in Indy.

Best pizza in indy. Nice that you can swing in and buy a slice as well. Only thing keeping it from a 10 would be that the pizza quality can vary from time to time. Broad ripple location has the better pies, downtown has the better atmosphere

Good pie, nice crust and crispy undercarriage, sauce and cheese are okay, all round solid slice

Probably the best pizza on the Broad Ripple strip

My go-to pizza in Indy for NY Style. Ordering a whole pie is a much better tasting experience than a slice off the rack, just fyi.

22in xtra cheese with ricotta. Absolutely amazing taste in cheese, crust is perfect like a breadstick. Will be coming back.

Solid pizza. Vibes always strong. Can’t go wrong.

Great flavor. Very little grease. Appreciate the balance of cheese to sauce. Crust wasn’t as crisp but pizza had also been sitting for a bit. Will definitely order again

Absolutely great late night food. Great football pizza too. Very greasy.

Solid pizza with a unique cheese blend.

Little sauce and a little doughy.

Good but not great. Need to check out the Goodfellas in downtown Indy! Good cheese good crisp soft sauce.

Personal favorite.

This place is always fire af especially after a night drinking in bripp. I prefer my pizza super saucy and this place definitely doesn’t put enough so for me I gotta order a whole pie made fresh with extra sauce. If you’re anywhere near here give this place a shot

Nice flavor for a late night place- holding it back from an 8 was the cheese and a crust that needs some crisp. Still a nice spot in Indy to go back to!

Really the only real New York style pizza around here, this is what the Ninja turtles eat!

Great pizza just needed I little more crisp

Decent slice. Nothing bad about it just nothing remarkable about it either. You don’t take a bit and say mmmmm that’s good. Feel like they need to add more to the sauce to give it more taste, cause it’s lacking as is. Just decent.

Another NYC-Style but that’s because it’s good pizza. Called in a half plain, half pepperoni 22” pie and it was ready to go when we walked in. Good slice size, solid fold, solid cheese and sauce. No crunch, which was disappointing. Chewy, which isn’t what you want, but just the right amount of grease. Overall, the plan in there, but the execution fell just short.

Great late night food. Had to wait in an uber for 35 mins before eating so I had to deduct .5 for that. Lot of flop. Ok crust. INCREDIBLE ranch.