Solid pizza with a unique cheese blend.
brad.brinkman11/26/18, 6:00 p.m.
Great pizza, I highly recommend stopping by! Can’t beat their lunch special, $6 for a huge slice a huge breadstick and a drink.
aaron.rogers9/25/18, 10:25 p.m.
I have been to Goodfellas close to ten time. The first time I went I ordered a whole pizza and the slices in that box we’re not as good as when sold individually.. they also have incredible, as long as your arm breadsticks Pizza 8.4 full experience 8.9
bambrose.ass9/4/18, 1:47 p.m.
Nestled along the banks of the mighty White River lies Goodfellas Pizzeria. I didn’t know anything this good could be in Indianapolis since Peyton Manning and his 60 pound head left for Denver, but I was mistaken. This pizza made me love again. Unlike the rap artist “Future”, this pizza did not have too much sauce. There was crispy crust, yet the pizza was not too dry. The pepperoni was well dispersed and the cheese had solid coverage. This might be the White Claws talking (I had a few at the pool before getting pizza 😮😮😜😜) but I believe Goodfellas to be the best pizza in the area! Every other pizza place’s ass is now in the jackpot! Zawk!
elliott.stevens8/28/18, 5:47 p.m.
Solid, New York flop with the perfect pepperoni-to-cheese ratio. The crust is the best I’ve seen in Indianapolis. Keeps you light on your feet all day long. Eight point two.