Goodfellas Pizzeria

Best pizza I’ve ever had, the first bite crunch is out of this world. Sauce and cheese match perfectly together and the crust tops it off. It is a little heavy but the box is definitely worth getting the 22”.

Amazing first bite crisp. Crust is packed with flavors and cheese tops off a great pizza. Little heavy, would not recommend the 22 incher.

Love the crust and flavor

Great NYC pizza in Indy

had it long ago, saw that dave gave it a solid review. Not impressed but the crust is phenomenal, does feel like a new york slice but the ingredients didnt stand out wt all

OMG love this pizza and breadstick

Good service quality pizza

Had the 16” lots of flop, not very Crisp.. I would only go out of my way for Goodfellas because most other pizza shops in downtown are borderline 6s. Overall good taste, but think maybe Dave was feeling generous in his review.

Fire pie

Dave was spot on with his review.. Fantastic cheese and light sauce combined with the huge slices makes this a great pie!

Heavy flop, definitely a folding pizza. Really solid all the way around.

The sauce is lacking.

One of my favorite pizzas