Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave.

Pleasantly surprised. Pizza was lighter than it looked w good flavor. Crust was crunchy and airy and sauce and cheese had some tang. Slices are huge and remind me of the Jersey shore boardwalk slices. If I lived here it would satisfy my itch but would not hold up in NY.

First time in Indianapolis, first pizza place, was a fantastic pizza. 8.2 that’s my review

Great sauce. Decent crust. Not an amazing pizza but it is great

Very cheesy. Lots of homeless inside/outside the restaurant. Came back a second time and giving it the same score.

Too doughy, too cheesy. Reminded me of Geraci's Slice Shop in downtown Cleveland, which was trash too. I think I would have been better off getting a slice & having it reheated in the oven.

Fluffy yet crisp, very good overall, cool place to visit.

Great sauce and crust is very good. Cooked to perfection but something just wasn’t special about it so solid 7.4.

the crust is to die for

Best pizza in Indy. The 1/2 price bourbon on Tuesday is awesome

Very crispy crust which I love! Cheese a lil overcooked and needs more sauce

By far the best pizza I’ve had! Perfect, crisp crust!

As someone from NY i was surprised by Dave’s score. This is not NY pizza. It was doughy and chewy, and sauce and cheese were different in different spots of pizza. Definitely not worth driving to get, you can get this pizza from a chain

Light flavor thin and crispy really simple and done well, could’ve been cooked a bit longer for it to be above a 8.5

Little bit too much garlic taste

Solid slice. A lil burn but good

best pizza in indiana. no questions asked.

Ordered half cheese, half pepperoni and mushrooms. Whole pizza was pepperoni and mushrooms. They gave us free desert for the mistake. Good taste, good crisp.

FIRE.

Presidente was right.

I give this place a 7. Want to see why? Look me up on TikTok or instagram Pizza_chomper69 follow me for more