I think Dave just about hit it on the nail with this score. I’ve been to many of the same spots as Dave and this is the first time I’ve ever scored the same exact thing as him. Couldn’t go lower or higher. I went to Goodfellas in Cincinnati and got a pizza by the slice. I got a 16 inch half and half pie here. I felt this location and getting it by the whole pie was much better than the Cincy location.
pouchpizza5/5/22, 11:07 p.m.
Great crisp on crust, cheese is good, sauce has fresh taste, huge pepperonis but no crisp like I prefer
chief21175/1/22, 12:47 p.m.
Not the same pizza Stool Presidente had when he wrote his review. This pie reminded me of Papa John’s or DiGiorno…it was trash. Counter staff had zero personality and almost as little a clue. Don’t be fooled into thinking you’re getting a NY style slice, it couldn’t be further from it.
newjerseydevil4/8/22, 11:52 p.m.
Good one here. Cheese was super good quality. No flop. If it was a little more done, it would be in the 8s.
trevan.clark2312/3/21, 12:13 a.m.
Excellent Pizza. Best in Indy. Huge slices. Awesome. And great cookies
asianpizzadude11/28/21, 12:13 a.m.
Decent slice. Kind of floppy and the sauce could use work. Overall not too bad
15 views•1 like
abby.plsek11/14/21, 10:43 p.m.
Really good New York style pizza. They sell the biggest pizzas I’ve ever seen and you can just get a slice if you want. They’re breadsticks are also huge and very delicious
rushfan-duhpizzareviewdude11/13/21, 10:38 p.m.
Greasy. And unless I’m nuts, salty. Crust doesn’t hold up. Major flop. Taste of all tree ingredients fair. Sauce is best of three. I’m hungry and I don’t like this a little. Not enough sauce to boot.
indycontrarian11/13/21, 7:49 p.m.
I agree with El Prez, really good pizza. And huge. Solid in all aspects. Good crust, cheese and sauce.
mikeypageviews10/30/21, 3:00 a.m.
We got the Goodfella, the Tommy Two Time and a custom Chicken and tomato. The Buff cheese bread was as good as the pizza! We are going with El Pres on this one.
steven.davis49/24/21, 9:45 p.m.
Solid pizza overall. A bit greasy in the middle, difficult to keep the cheese on the slice. Undercarriage is nicely crisp. Sauce and cheese has good flavor, and lovely air bubbles to enjoy. Service was fast and friendly. 7.4 combined score.
justin.hill78/25/21, 4:34 p.m.
Giant floppy grease ball. Dough is good but I don’t get all the hype. The flavor reminds me of really good dominos—good drunk pizza but would go out of my way for it
davidharleyjr8/14/21, 4:10 p.m.
Good size slices but $6 per Great crisp without being burnt Sauce is nice but not enough parm in the blend, lacking that salty-ness $13+ for two slices 6.8
trevor.capps8/1/21, 5:35 p.m.
Very very good combination of crisp crust, flavorful sauce and expertly melted cheese. The talk of this being Indy’s best pizza is not unfounded. If it’s not #1 it is definitely top 5.
derek.hamm7/30/21, 8:14 p.m.
Wow this is the best slice of pizza I’ve ever had. Buffalo has better football but Indy is where the pizza is at. Perfect slice I couldn’t ask for anything better. Immaculate flavors all around, love the cheese, and the sauce is very tasty. The crust is very nice crispy with good flavor. Love me some New York slices this is the perfect slice in my opinion. I don’t know how this could ever be topped. If goodfellas was at home I would eat this every day. I want to give this a higher rating but 9.4 fits the slice
alex.givens7/28/21, 11:54 p.m.
Slices are massive taste is good. I’ve tasted this same pizza at other places
mrcampop7/25/21, 6:25 p.m.
Holy crap this is good. Best pizza I've had out of New York. And the pie is Huge at a whopping 22in!
j.b1017/10/21, 11:35 p.m.
Nice sauce to cheese ratio. The crust is cooked on the bottom nicely but it is a thick pie.