Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave

Really good pizza. Service wasn’t great. Called in an order, the call in line wasn’t well thought out. The pizza was about 10 minutes past the pickup time before it was ready and the people were slightly rude about it.

I have the worst luck…. So sad about this rush job of a pizza

Nice thin and crispy pizza.

Solid NY slice for Indy. No flop, light, nice crisp bite. Good cheese to sauce ratio. My rebake was probably a bit too long as the crumb came out too crisp, but I’ve had a chewier bite here before. Good lunch specials. You could easily come here for lunch regularly.

Scored before adding spices. Solid pie, worth the trip. Best in Indy

It’s good but pizza is a little floppy.

Wasn’t floppy taste good

White was better than the pepperoni and sausage. Crust was very good. The rest was meh. 7.3 for the white, 6.5 for the sausage and pepperoni.

Solid slice! Lighter on the sauce than i personally care for thus my slightly lower score but definitely an excellent place for great NY Style pizza! Nice and big slice, crunch present almost the whole slice.

Really really big! And good stuff

Absolutely insane bottom crust, cooked to perfection. Enough to feed a family for $10. Simply can’t beat that..

Pleasantly surprised. Pizza was lighter than it looked w good flavor. Crust was crunchy and airy and sauce and cheese had some tang. Slices are huge and remind me of the Jersey shore boardwalk slices. If I lived here it would satisfy my itch but would not hold up in NY.

Great sauce. Decent crust. Not an amazing pizza but it is great

Very cheesy. Lots of homeless inside/outside the restaurant. Came back a second time and giving it the same score.

Too doughy, too cheesy. Reminded me of Geraci's Slice Shop in downtown Cleveland, which was trash too. I think I would have been better off getting a slice & having it reheated in the oven.