Goodfella's Pizzeria

No sauce bland cheese ok crisp and crust

Hey, it ain’t the worst! But it tastes cheap. Doesn’t really have a good cheese taste and not nearly enough sauce! The dough was alright - I guess. It has a lot of flaws but it’s not the worst thing I’ve tasted.

Been here maybe four times nothing special. Not worth going back to. Need paper towels to mop up the grease.

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Goodfella’s Pizzeria, and I can confidently say it exceeded my expectations. I ordered the Sicilian Goodfella’s specialty, and it was a delightful experience from start to finish. The crust was perfectly crispy, while the toppings were generous and flavorful, creating a harmonious blend that left me wanting more. Each bite was a testament to the care and attention put into crafting their pizzas. As a first-time visitor, I was truly impressed by the quality and presentation of my meal. The atmosphere of the pizzeria added to the overall experience, making it a welcoming place to enjoy a delicious slice. I can't wait to return and explore more of their menu. Goodfella’s is definitely a new favorite!

Classic football pie. Good crisp nothing special

No flop, crispy, flavorful pizza. Another plus is they have the best garlic knots in town!

Average.

Crust is excellent but lacking a bit on flavor. Would come back though

Good sauce and cheese. Alittle greasy but a good pizza

Chewy and not much flavor, but that's Florida pizza.

Quality hometown pizza. A little on the greasy side with New York flop. Sauce is excellent but would have liked to have more on the pie.

A lot of flop and dripping with oil, very good pizza with a lot of flavor.

The most authentic New York style pizza around UCF and you're nuts if you don't try it

Looks can be deceiving but this ain’t it chief average slice

Not much sauce. Flavor kind of lacking. Not a memorable slice at all.

Little flop, little bit of grease, crust has a nice crunch just not very memorable. Almost a little bit of like a Chuck E. Cheese taste. But good lunch deal $7 for a salad and two slices

Used to be the best pizza in the area back in the day. Still a decent pie.