Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR

Midfellas (tried the new Columbus location). Decent crust but overall lacked flavor, reminded me of cafeteria pizza. Shoutout Z Got

Atmosphere and service a plus. Not a pie I would drive an hour or more to enjoy,, but not a bad pie. Service was good. Atmosphere as well. Frankly, I expected more of a place called Goodfellas… That said, I’d come here again and order another pie. Just m or it’s not going to win any awards from Most Amazing Pizza in Cincinnati. My Scoring System: * Always a large cheese pizza * Always made to order * Always eaten at the establishment * Always eaten while fresh and hot > 9.0 = Travel out of state or 4+ hours for the pizza. This is World-Class Pizza! > 8.0 = Travel 1 to 3 hours for the pizza. This is Local Legend Pizza > 7.0 = Local pizza that is a go-to. Very good pizza. > 6.0 = If you’re already there then you go for it. It’s not a bad pie but you’re not going out of your way for it. < 5.9 = Worsening levels of MEH. Gas station heat lamp to school lunch lady pizza. You’ll feel the dead weight in you. Hard pass (pun intended). Atmosphere and service adds/drops up to .5 points: Add 0.0 for polite service Add 0.1 for good service Add 0.2 for great service Add 0.3 for phenomenal service Add 0.4 for legendary service Add 0.5 for epic service that can only be done here Subtract 0.1 to 0.5 for meh, distracted, bad, awful, and find another job, respectively.

crunch can be heard from the state over, cheese is great and the sauce is alright. could be the biggest slice ever! Great pizza

Good pizza eat here and drink beer!!!

Good crisp & No flop

Good sauce

Their pizza has always been special to me. And their ranch is even better.

Big ass pizza on a cold ass day…… 7.6 Easy.

(Pepperoni pizza) Crust is the best part. Crispy and doughy yet not crunchy. Secondly the cheese is okay. Sauce is mildly rich and more sweet. Pepperoni is like cafeteria/frozen pizza. It would be better if made to order and not from under a heat lamp. Still a good pizza above most making it sit in the eight range

Pizza is so good, if not floppy. Mix that with a great whiskey bar and you get a great score.

Solid pizza, decent crisp, not much grease and not much flop. If the sauce had a little more tang it would be in the 8s.

Dear lord this is amazing. Great flavor, great crust, rock solid all around

Good crisp…. Decent pepperoni. Need more spunk in the sauce though.

What’s slightly above dominos THIS !

Much better than a 0.0. :) A bit doughy but good taste. Good luck eating more than 2 slices though….

Better than the slice I had at their Pleasant Ridge location. This one was on point. Very solid New York slice.

Institutional. Moving on.

Definitely glad I stopped here while in town. Not my favorite pizza I’ve had in Ohio, but not bad. My slice had lots of grease and was very heavy. Had to fold it completely up to eat it. Cheese was falling off too. My friends enjoyed it more than I did. But the price is very good. $3 for a slice or a $7 meal for a slice, side, and a drink. Overall nice little place inside.