My first major disappointment so far in my journey of NYC pizza. There was a ton of flop, and an overwhelming amount of grease. It was definitely super cheesy, but that couldn’t be helped by the brittle crust underneath. The crust itself had a bumpy texture that didn’t help with its overall taste or ability to be handled and eaten easily.
delicious_mike4/13/21, 7:19 p.m.
Really enjoyed the cheese. Thin crust with a little flop. Always enjoy a nice bubble. Enjoyed this slice!
jbo8/25/20, 11:42 p.m.
fine slice, would be better hot. Pep is the best part of this but the cheese is lacking. Sauce is good but there isn’t much of it. At best a decent slice, nothing to write home about.
landon.calhoun8/17/20, 8:20 p.m.
Unusually strong for Gotham, but this time around was very good. Certifiably Crispy™️ crust with strong sauce and good cheese to sauce ratio. No excess grease.
cody.ross281/10/19, 9:32 p.m.
First review. First NYC pizza. I know it gets better than this. Is that panko on the crust? I think the highlight was the garlic knots
spencer43369/15/18, 4:32 p.m.
The sauce wasn’t bad, the crust was pretty disappointing though.