Greenbush Bar

Wow wow wow. Get the meatballs on the pizza you won’t regret it, grab the tiramisu before you leave.

Solid

Incredibly thin, crisp and delicious. Bit more sauce and it would be a 9.1. Ordered bacon + garlic and it was perfect. Great ambience, speakeasy, tiramisu!

Margarita pizza not on the menu but defiantly order this! It’s probably the thinnest and crispiest pizza I’ve ever had!

One of the best under carriages I’ve ever had and everything was so fresh. Highly recommend and such a cool place to eat and grab a drink

It’s aight. There have been better places. Did not get atrocious burps like sbenda.

Best pizza in Madison and it’s not close

AMAZING! I ordered this one with extra cheese, it was perfect!

I’ve only given two 8+ scores ever. This is the second. Absolutely incredible. Best pizza I’ve had in Wisconsin

The crust was the best part. Not sure if it was the garlic bread before hand but the burping after was atrocious

Greenbush bar opening in 1993. Basically in basement of the Italians Workmen’s club. Reminds me when I went to Monte Bello in South St Louis. Place is packed in basement. Low ceiling. Good vibes. $17 for one topping 12 inch. Very good bar pie. Cornmeal crust was a little thicker that I would have liked it to be but it was a very simple and tasty pizza with great sauce and cheese.

Looked great. Had higher expectations from the taste though. The crust was not crispy, the marinara was really tasty, but the cheese was not that great either. Overall worth a try but not among the better pizzas out there.

Great pie, thinny thin. Simple and well made.

one bite everyone knows the rules

Fantastic