Grimaldi's Pizzeria

The best you’ll find in this area. Though Neapolitan, the incredible sauce and crust gets it into the 8’s. ESP in this area of the country.

My favorite pizza restraunt in Las Vegas so when this opened had to try. Temp I know play a factor with coal temps amd we went on a hot humid day. Vegas this is a 9.3 pizza but on this day it's an 8.6 for me. Asked for extra time in oven becuz of the weather but the middle was still a bit floppy. Still the best pizza in Wisconsin

If you are looking for East Coast Pizza. This is it.

By far the best pizza in the Milwaukee area. There are no pizzas here to compare with. The only NY style around.

One of the best pizzas I’ve had around Milwaukee. A little floppy due to the thinness, but it has a nice crunchy undercarriage with a soft top - my ideal crust situation. Toppings are very fresh and it was cooked to perfection. Will be returning.

Need a touch more cheese other wise decent

Ordered take out. Pizza looked good. Quality ingredients. Had to reheat once we got home so probably would be higher if dining in. Free appetizer when signing up for rewards program was a nice surprise. Would order again.

I’ve been all over Rhode Island and Massachusetts. I’m giving us a 91. I back it up. This pizza is the best I’ve had in Wisconsin. And better than most in the Northeast.

Tldr: great presentation, weak on flavor. Pie looks amazing. Thin, very light pizza. I didn't feel guilty eating the full 18". Very crispy with a good under carriage, which I spotted the manager check on every pizza as it came out. The big downside however is just how BLAND the pizza tasted. Sauce was average, cheese was on the pizza, but I could barely tell.

Great NY style. Fresh. Love the old school ambience.

7.2 All Day. Lite, tasty, football pizza. Some of the best NY style in the area sadly. Still not as good as a true NY slice.

Very good coal fired with crisp. Good flavor. I got the pesto pizza with roccotta cheese

Can taste the fresh ingredients

One of my favorite pizzas in SE Wisconsin. Only coal fired oven in the area. Great sauce, crispy crust. Fantastic.

Very good pizza pie!!!