Guido's original NY Style pizzeria downtown

Pretty damn greasy. Sauce was good- 2 out of 4 of us went straight to the shitter. Ordered crispy.... the flop would have probably been crazy if not for

This is legit NYC style pizza. Great crisp and char and tasty, zesty sauce. Bit greasy, but overall a solid slice.

Solid New York Style. A bit of flop, great crust! A little greasy, but mostly from the pepperoni. Probably the best pizza in the valley

Best New York Style Pizza that I’ve had in Idaho! I think it’s a “conveyor belt” pie. A little greasy but NO flop! Very tasty. I love this place.

Got the original and the tomato basil ham. Thin crust, great undercarriage, good flavor, little flop. Definitely a go too.

Very good pizza with not too much flop and the perfect amount of flavor! Crust was flaky and cooked perfectly🤝

Got cheese and cheese with basil. Both solid, greasy. Thin. Decent flavor. Hits the spot better than any others in Boise. Reggie Jackson photo on the wall. Good form. 7.3

Favorite pizza in Boise

Choney bandits official review

Very good pizza, Good sauce Excellent crust!

Great light crisp crust full flavored sauce good cheese basic pepperoni

Basil cheese slice has above average flavor, but it's also above average greasy.

Good crisp, Basil and cheese is the go to. Nice flavor in the sauce and cheese is just right.

Favorite pizza joint in Idaho !

Alright Frankie Here at guidos,5 th street downtown Boise...great looking shop, good people and down to brass tax,,, pizza looks awesome on view, crust is thin and crispy through every bite, sauce had good tang and zero grease... solid 8.9

Decent piece of pizza, ordered a slice of cheese. Nice undercarriage, solid crust, light crisp, thin pizza. Too much tomato towards the crust but overall pizza is a little bland. Overall very decent New York “style” drunk pizza.

Very Good!

Excellent NY-style slice. Great cheese, light, and good sauce.

Football pizza all the way! Solid number 1 right down the middle. Great tang on the sauce and great cheese. Crust was surprising crispy with a good looking undercarriage, no Rocky Mountain flop here Blakie! This pizza plays... this pizza plays anywhere. Worth a stop on your way to the hot springs, if your so inclined.

Great pizza! Crust is really good and the sauce is phenomenal!!

Tastiest sauce there is. Period. You know the rules

Just your basic football pizza, Frankie. Nothin special, but you get what you pay for. No gimmicks. The heater right down the middle of the plate. Good size for the cost. Nice local place to support when you're in the mood for something a little greasier.