Gus's New York Pizza

Fluffy pizza. Really light on the sauce. Cheese is not bad. The dough is pretty decent.

Good slice, great if you love a cheesy pizza. Sauce has a sweet hint to it but is overpowered by the flavor of the cheese. Amazing crust flavor but definitely could be a bit crispier.

Ingredients are really good. Undercarriage is good too. If it was just a little bit crispier I’d go higher. Otherwise for cheap quick pizza at any hour this is my go to

It's a pizza place, open 24 hours and in the middle of ASU, essentially. Not the greatest.

Pizza review time

One of my favorite slices in the valley, better than the dollar slices I tried in Manhattan. The sauce is a little spicy, the cheese is nice and greasy and the crust is a perfect thin and floppy crust.

Easily an 8.2

Pizza has a bit a flop but sauce still has a nice tang and well-developed flavors.

Decent pie especially for a 24hr spot

The staff are super friendly and kind. The wait time is not long at all and the atmosphere is great. Crust snapped when I picked up every slice. Sauce is very simple and basic with very little tang, sweetness, spice or much of anything. The cheese is very standard. All in all the pizza is decent if you want something quick and you’re walking distance from here but otherwise there are much better spots a short drive. One but everybody knows the rules, obviously this entire pizza went in my stomach solely due to massive hunger.

This is drunk pizza. Nothing too special but it’s pizza.

Too cheesy, way too greasy, massive flop. Really lacking a good sauce.

Solid pie

I know it ain’t cheese, but I’m feeling squirrelly, so we’re rocking pepperoni tonight. Service was top notch. Crust was a 7.9 sauce is a 6.1 cheese is a 7. 4, and pep is a 8.1, overall, 7.3

Good crisp, needs more cheese

One bite everybody knows the rules. There are 2 pizza places available for delivery after 12am and this is the second best. About the most average pizza you can think of.