Hawthornes New York Pizza & Bar

Barely any sauce on the pie. Crust was doughy and tough to chew. Cheese wasn’t good.

Cold hard cheese in no way is this cheese pizza worth $20! How is this place even in business!?

Little flop, good sauce, needs more crisp. Missing a pop

Great crust, sauce/cheese ratio is good. I’ve had the NYC style at other locations, Sicilian style is better. Also, get a side garlic knots, probably the best I’ve ever had...

Crispy, greasy,Sauce is a little different. Pretty good

Floppy, grease bomb. Asked for it well done but it came soft and sloppy. Taste is something out of a 7-11

Great pie not to saucey amazing crust

Decent slice, not sure it has the freshness and amount of sauce to rate higher. Good dough and crust.

Crust was good, just a little flop, but it was greasy.

Decent pizza with a massive flop!

I came in with high expectations, this pizza was just okay, nothing special. Too much grease and cheese/crust felt like a store-bought pie.

Better than expected. Their small pies are well put together with less slop and flop. Good baked crust and the CBR pie is decent as well. Far better than the Elizabeth location. Inconsistent.

I would agree with the el prez that this is a average pizza. The cheese and sauce didn't really have in flavor to it. The dough was cooked perfect with right amount of crisp.

Almost thought I was missing sauce until I got to the back of my first slice. Sauce was tangy and delicious... wish it had more. Cheese and crust solid with the right amount of grease.

Solid 5.