Hillary's Chicago Pizza St. Augustine

I was super excited to try the cheese and then my normal slice. So dissatisfied. The crust tastes like cornmeal. There’s no integrity to the crust. Not good. The people that are writing these reviews must be friends of the owners. This place is the worst I found in Saint Augustine and I’ve tried all of them. I hate the yellow corn meal chewy crust.

Deep dish and thin crust were both very good

Excellent Chicago Style Pizza! Took family who grew up in Chicago and they agreed with its authenticity! Great taste and extra filling.

Great deep dish! Also the salad is amazing, I’ll be back for a normal style za because of how good this place is. Don’t be in a hurry if you’re dining in for deep dish, they take their time and do it right.

Fantastic! Loved the thin crust.

Excellent pizza, thin and crispy pub style. I did not try the deep dish.

A taste of Chicago in the oldest city in America