Holy Tomato Pies

Honey Buffalo Chicken is to die for. This is one of the best pizzas I have ever eaten. My wife keeps ordering all the time.

Overall very good pie. Good sauce and tasted fresh… laid back atmosphere with a friendly staff

Some real good stuff here nice and flavorful and thin crisp crust and great vibe in the place. Freah ingredients all over the place .The salad gets a 8.3 and

half “Parma” and half Boardwalk. I’m a sauce guy and I’d do both again - the Parma is just so my style as it has a bit more oregano and spices. Place had an awesome vibe to it too.

Such a good quality pizza with fresh ingredients, a thin crust and a good crunch on the crust

Amazing. Crisp, delicious flavor, homemade taste. Highly recommend

Really good pizza. Quality ingredients. Tasty sauce. Can tell there would be a phenomenal crunch. Probably arrived 25 minutes after it was ready to be picked up. But I did arrive on time. Score could have only gone up.

M Score: 5.8 Crust: 2.5 Cheese: 2.0 Sauce: 1.1 Bonus: .2 Ranch? No “REALLY salty. Cheese was good, just poorly covered on the pie. Lots of bites with no cheese. Crust is almost like a cracker, a delicious cracker. It’s unique, I’m probably rating it too high. Lastly, the way it is cut is so damn weird, really not into it.” J Score: 5.7 Crust: 2.2 Cheese: 2.0 Sauce: 1.0 Bonus: .5 Ranch? No “It’s like a very unwelcoming salty flavor. I like how the sauce has texture, it’s not smooth. I just can’t get past the saltiness. The mozzarella itself is fresh but also salty. If the cheese is salty, then the sauce shouldn’t be. Bonus awarded for fresh chopped garlic. It adds texture and an extra bite.” *Should be noted somewhere that the staff is really nice

New fav!

Similar to Delorenzo’s but not as crispy. Still fucking fantastic.

If you want the best pizza EVER….go to Holy Tomato. Terry the Owner is amazing. Pizza is amazing! ❤️🍕

Couldn’t wait to have some before the picture. Definitely my favorite pizza in the tri-state area

This place caught me off guard big time!!!! The garlic is real too, sauce is fantastic crust incredible and thin. I was unsure if this place would live up to the hype I heard and smashed it!!! This deserves to be in the conversation with the best if not an argument as the best. The guy too and the place are a ten he new what he was giving me. If your considering this run don’t walk.

The experience from arrival to being seated was amazing!!! The atmosphere is definitely great! Now for the pizza! The undercarriage very nicely done amazing crunch with every bite and all the way to the crust. The sauce was amazing and you can definitely tell this is homemade and alot of work was put in to the sauce. It is definitely a spot worth checking out!!!

Good crunch on the outside but flops on the inside. Great Flavor with some tang. I must say the Buffalo Chicken Pizza was without a doubt the best I've had.

Thin, crispy, fresh tomato sauce, enough cheese, little garlicky, good pizza.

Thin/crispy/great sauce with crushed garlic. Can’t beat it. Best pizza in NJ. Have heard it compared to DeLorenzos tomato pies...holy tomato blows them out of the water. El pres give em a score.

Perfect char, crust, sauce and cheese, perfect everything! Best in NJ

Delicious white pie. Great people. Even better pizza.