I always have the same reaction when having pizza from Homestyle: this should be better. A bit heavy on the cheese and the crust is rather doughy. The sauce has a nice tang but overall it falls short of being anything other than decent.
beastnipples8/29/21, 5:00 p.m.
Decent thick square. Nothing blows me away but a decent slice. Sauce is a bit salty.
olleitacsum3/21/21, 11:29 p.m.
Cheese slice had a nice crisp on the crust but underdone in the middle, suuuper floppy. When I held it up the entire slice except for the crust was pointing straight down. Sauce was good, cheese ok but a little burnt. Square white with tomato gets a 6.7, solid slice
cpbennice4/6/20, 4:21 p.m.
Awesome Mom & Pop near Rivers Casino! Great eggplant & meatballs too
chrisspizzareviews10/17/19, 6:16 p.m.
It just looks sad doesn’t it? Super cheesy, not in a way. I used to think their pizza was good, maybe it was the square pizza. This is not, was not good. Not cooked all the way, doughy, I didn’t like the sauce and the overload of mozzarella. Not for me 5.9
justin.brock95/22/19, 1:44 p.m.
Pizza before 10 am never taste so good. Boss brought in a couple breakfast Za’s. Bacon Scrambie Eggs, crispy crust. What a start to the day. 7.8
corey.tines5/14/19, 10:33 p.m.
I think a 6.7 is fair... not a huge fan of their pizza, usually go for their other entrees. (Eggplant parm is an easy 8.2)
123 views•4 likes
paizan42610/1/18, 4:29 a.m.
A Nisky hotspot for a long time, run by the family of “Mr. Monday Night” Joe Tessitore, Pizza was good, nice crisp crust. On a non pizza note, they don’t toss their wings in sauce, you’ve gotta specifically ask them to. Weird man.