Usually this place is one of my favorite spots. However I came here on a Monday and it was just OK. Maybe it was just an off night. I even brought a friend since I had been talking this place up. Sauce was pretty bland and the pizza barely had any flavor. The crust also wasn’t crunchy like it typically is.
david.s.armstrong2/3/23, 11:32 p.m.
Smokin’ Joe’s crust, regular sauce with pepperoni. This pizza had a lot of Crust, a lot! Zero flop, crispy, light yeast flavor. The toppings weren’t evenly spread but the cheese had a decent tang. Had this place before, something was missing this time.
sam.vine2/27/22, 4:23 p.m.
Great pizza, a little floppy which isn’t preferred… has a nice little crunch but still a fluffy crust… the spicy sauce definitely bumps this score up, even though it’s not too spicy. Great taste and overall mouth feel. I highly recommend it and that’s a pizza review
carson.labensky2/27/22, 4:10 p.m.
Solid pizza, spicy sauce is definitely the way to go. Wish the crust was a little more crisp.
pizzaking4410/8/21, 5:44 p.m.
Smokin’ Joes crust (garlic butter thicc crust cut into triangles) with Original Sauce. The toppings are not a usual when doing multiple ratings but having had Hounddogs before I knew their really good pepperoni was a must. Although thicc the undercarriage wasn’t heavy and had a nice little flop. The Original sauce was great sweet but not nearly as sweet as you would think. I really enjoyed this pizza and the crust that served as a garlic breadstick when finished. P.S. the Lasagna Bites as an appetizer we’re phenomenal! (I am super critical and I would defiantly recommend this place if you like thicc(er) pizza. Perhaps choose square cuts. It was fork & knife when it first arrived at our table. Excellent service.
paulowry9/15/21, 3:26 p.m.
Not Dave’s style but definitely my style. Amazing pizza and I get it every time I’m in Cbus.
benny.p558/22/21, 10:36 p.m.
Best spot in Columbus. Good sauce good cheese. Gotta get smokin Joe’s crust
rynekrall8/20/21, 12:57 a.m.
I got the Smokin Joes crust with the original sauce. The crust wasn’t too hard or burnt. Had a lot of cheese which I liked. The sauce had a nice tang. Pretty solid pie.
hastalapizza7/24/21, 11:57 p.m.
I have no idea how this pizza is scored so high. Very disappointed.
paul.o46/26/21, 7:55 p.m.
Amazing pizza. Got a 16" with sausage and pepperoni with mushrooms on one half and green olives on the other half. Hand tossed crust with garlic. Little flop and good crisp on the under carriage. One of the best crusts I have had yet. Sauce has very good flavor. Pizza was hot when it came out. Right amount of cheese. This pizza is one of most flavorable pizzas I have had yet. Stellar.
brennan.hunt5/24/21, 1:02 a.m.
Best za around OSU campus. Smokin’ Joe crust is a must. Meat lovers is elite
cameron.young425/13/21, 3:46 p.m.
Held a piece up so you can see there is no flop. In other pictures I could tell some did have flop maybe it’s different depending on who is working or maybe they corrected it. The pie I got had great undercarriage, great crisp, the crust is true to pan style. Real pop with the sauce. Mad decent pie.
joedavis224/29/21, 2:23 a.m.
Sauce and pep are solid. Crust though is way too doughy. And the cheese too stringy. Lots of flop.