Hup's Pizza

Don’t shoot me (seriously don’t) but if this Pie was in the burbs there wouldn’t be a dry pair of khakis for miles. Grab a pack of Newps and head to the hood to cream ur jeans.

Jerry gave it a 7.5. I thought crust with solid and cheese/toppings ok. Sauce meh. Very greasy. Getting the pizza then taking it home to make it well done is a good option.

Portnoy would like this

Cheese pizza had great flavor. Thick cheese, but not too thick. Crust was crispy but had a hint of the undercooked flavor (in a great way). Sauce is good too. One of the best I’ve had in Milwaukee.

Good pizza. Would’ve made the 8’s had it been cooked longer.

When ordering it’s carryout only. Cash only. Pro tip: ask them not to cut the pizza then when you get home throw it in the oven to crisp it up. My only complaint is that they don’t leave their pizzas in the oven long enough. Otherwise my score would be in the 9’s.

The legendary Hups is one of the best. Sausage/Pepperoni should really be the gold standard pizza and their sturdy thin crust with those toppings are impressive. A little greasy but who cares when it’s that good.

Best Pizza in Milwaukee