Ian’s Pizza Madison | State Street

Hits the spot. Strong score

Solid crust / undercarriage. Extremely greasy.

Straight up worst pizza I’ve had in a long time. It literally tastes like nothing- the Mac and cheese pizza tastes like unflavored noodles just horrible! The cheese is so sub- par- I can’t believe Dave gave this place a decent review- horrible compared to literally anything in Chicago!

Sober score

Should’ve tried this one Pres

Very good crust, solid cheese, sauce. A little greasy, but overall very solid

They were out of plain, so I tried a couple of others. Good crust, but overall just kind of average.

Solid pizza by the slice on a college campus, known for their random pizza options!

Solid slice. Bumped into the 8s.

Score rated on MnC slice, which I believe is their flagship pizza. Good crisp on thin crust style 8 sliced pie. Outer crust is firm outside and a little (pleasantly) chewy inside. Noodles fine firmness/texture with mildly salted seemly two cheese blend on top. Would get again, ate half an extra large between this and the Schmo.

When you come to Ians, you get the BBQ Chicken. Crispy, perfectly cooked slice with bacon, chicken, cheese, BBQ sauce, and ranch. Its heaven in a slice.

Most famous pizza in Madison but toppings make it worse. Solid real review with no toppings

Nothing remarkable. Sauce is somewhat bland. Suitable football pizza.

2AM classic, nothing better in Madison.

Slices pictured are cheese and one of the daily specials (Italian beef and giardenara). This review is on the cheese only. Was too greasy for my liking, it was dripping off the slice. Sauce flavor did not standout. Crust was pretty decent. I want to try again but make sure I get a fresh slice next time.

Solid. Not great. I judge on cheese only

Crunchy crust but not over cooked, good taste, good amount of sauce and cheese. Overall good pizza

Very overrated. Good pizza, just good. Not outstanding but a solid slice.