galactic_foodie12/28/20, 10:18 p.m.
Too much grease and a little too much flop. Other than that it's a pretty solid slice, not much flavor from the sauce though
gayoung.kim12/18/20, 8:24 p.m.
Extremely thin crust pizza to the point it’s hard to call it a “pizza” but delicious nonetheless! Perfect amount of sauce, cheese and grease level. Try it if you’re in downtown Sarasota for sure!
chris.ulery12/18/20, 8:23 p.m.
Cracker pizza! Very thin pizza, cheese was great, sauce was good, and held a nice crisp. Just got the slice rather than the whole pie, and had it been a little thicker crust, would have been mid to high 8’s. Well worth a trip and if you’re in the area, definitely stop.
steven.daniels12/16/20, 12:23 a.m.
Probably a little higher than it should be. But, this is top of the line pizza for Florida if you like a good N.Y. slice.
peter.young48/2/20, 7:56 p.m.
Perfect crisp all the way through the slice, robust tomatoy sauce and the right amount of cheese! Best slice I've ever had, but I'm from LA.
peter.young38/2/20, 7:45 p.m.
Oh my God so good the sauce of the flavor flavor of the sauce so crispy all the way through cheesy yum
nicholas.dipaolo8/15/19, 10:29 p.m.
Good flavor in the crust. A ton of grease on top. I feel sick to my stomach. They do not pre cook their sausage. The grease was all over my hands and plate.
paolomaldini3/12/19, 9:58 p.m.
Very thin crust and greasy. Need to clean up the grease. Average slice.
kayleigh.o'hora12/28/18, 9:46 p.m.
So it's good pizza, no question about it. But we were really surprised when we took our first bites that both ratings before us gave it such high scores. We're from MA and have had the pizza greats like John's of Bleeker, The original Regina in the North End, and the Original Frank Pepe's in New Haven and those are pizzas worthy of the praise they receive. This while tasty, doesn't hold a candle to those. This pizza is definitely New York style with the nice thin crust. Greasy as all hell, but it had a really nice flavor overall. Lots of flop to spare, but no problem eating it like a normal slice. We felt it was missing the nice charred bottom, and wished that the pizza had more crunch to it. Overall a good, enjoyable pie.
erinsrq12/13/18, 1:57 a.m.
The most New York like pizza in Sarasota. New York flop but with a crispy crust.
ma1tpizzaman12/13/18, 1:52 a.m.
Great crust, sauce was mild and not over powering. Pizza was greasy but good. Best pizza I’ve had in Sarasota and just got back from hitting some of the best spots in NYC.