Il Panificio USA

My buddy rated this at 7.5, but I'm giving it a score just under 7.4. It's a good everyday pizza that won't disappoint you. It's got good flavors, a bit of flop, and just the right amount of crunch for a thin pizza.

Best in sarasota

Pizza whore here. I’m not a purist and order my pie with different toppings. But I rate my score on crust, sauce, cheese and cut/type of toppings. Definitely a beautiful crust, thin without asking. I did order well done and a nice beautiful char. Nice chew / crispiness balance with char. (8.5) Sauce was nice. Not overwhelming but had a beautiful acidity and slight sweet overtone. Could have used more salt or seasoning but overall very good. (7.4) Cheese- good - not over done but good quality. (7.6) Pizza was not greasy but accentuated the balance of toppings, cheese and sauce. (8.6). Toppings were fresh and thin cut with care. (8.0). Service was great and takeaway 10 min before closing. Made me feel appreciated. Overall 8.4 and would order again. Going in for another bite 😄

One bite. Everybody knows the rules. A little soft on the undercarriage.

Literally the best pizza in Sarasota metro area. Doesn’t get better - I’ve had a slice or two in my day.

Very nice thin crust pizza with a good tang

Pretty good pizza. Very thin crust nice and stable, good cheese, little grease. Highly recommend especially for a slice place.

Excellent za. Very crispy and nicely seasoned

Good for just one slice but it's too greasy and oily, reminds me of chuck e. cheese pizza with the cheese flavor and bread texture but it's not that bad. more sauce would've helped imo but serviceable 7.1

firm crisp pizza.

This pizza is incredible! The thinnest crust. The best flavor. Unbelievable.

Waited over 2 hours to get it, so the score reflects that. Cheese is chewy almost like a mozzarella stick. Crust is pretty good, but greasy. Overall it’s pretty good, but not worth a 2 hour wait.

Too much grease and a little too much flop. Other than that it's a pretty solid slice, not much flavor from the sauce though

Extremely thin crust pizza to the point it’s hard to call it a “pizza” but delicious nonetheless! Perfect amount of sauce, cheese and grease level. Try it if you’re in downtown Sarasota for sure!

Cracker pizza! Very thin pizza, cheese was great, sauce was good, and held a nice crisp. Just got the slice rather than the whole pie, and had it been a little thicker crust, would have been mid to high 8’s. Well worth a trip and if you’re in the area, definitely stop.

Probably a little higher than it should be. But, this is top of the line pizza for Florida if you like a good N.Y. slice.

Perfect crisp all the way through the slice, robust tomatoy sauce and the right amount of cheese! Best slice I've ever had, but I'm from LA.