Island Slice Pizzeria

Thin crust is a flopfest. Greasy tourist trap terrible. GTTT!

Tastes like what a decent frozen slice would taste like.

Pizza was dry and the crust was doughy but had good flavor

Excellent taste, not much flop, toppings stayed on. Crust a bit hard but okay, good undercarriage.

Was part of family vacation and needed something to feed family. Well….this place was trash. $30 for a pizza that is on a Chuckie Cheese level. Awful.

Not super special.

it was as if they dunked the piece of pizza in this cauldron of broth. I was hungry so it was fine but it was a grease fest with a touch of sauce and cheese

Edible but not good. Scarcity is really keeping them open. I recommend maximizing toppings to make up for the lack of sauce, generic cheese, and doughy bread.

Lots of cheese, not much flop, somewhat greasy, good crust. A little pricey bc it Mackinac. Overall a good slice.

Actually had a day old slice reheated in the oven and was pleasantly surprised. Don't judge a book by its cover I thought it wouldn't get above a 3.8 but honestly I reheated it perfectly and surprisingly had a decent crunch and was actually not bad. Bet it would have been sex (6.9) or better when fresh out of the oven especially on mackinaw island I was shocked!!!!!!!

Basic pie, gets the job done

Nothing special but it will do the trick if you are in a bind.

Squishy heavy flop greasy no tang just bad dont spend the money

Very good flavor, pepperoni was very good!

Just a basic pizza slice. Nothing great about it.

Not great. Not terrible. Did the job after a round of golf. That’s a review Frankie!

No competition, must be a reason to not try