Islands Pizza Tavern

Zero flop

It’s got great sauce and lots of flavor. Just enough cheese to not be overpowering. A crisp crust and not greasy or oily.

One bite everyone knows the rules!!!

Great cheese to sauce ratio, must try in Tampa.

Best pizza in Tampa. Cheese is great, but the Brooklyn is amazing

Crust too soft

Solid undercarriage, little flop, a little bland. Overall decent but isn’t revolutionary

Sweet sauce and not overly greasy. Good crisp.

Decent pizza... not the best not the worst

Eh....cheese is burnt...sauce decent But go to the bar and see Linca Total smoke show!

Just got a slice and the score could fluctuate a couple decimals but crust was crispy, almost thin like a cracker, sauce was good, cheese was normal, great football pizza. I could smash this on a Sunday. 7.2.

A little to Much sauce but it is excellent tasting

Didn’t do traditional cheese. But the bacon buffalo ranch pizza was great. No ranch came on but we got some on the side and it could’ve used more bacon. But overall still a great pizza. Gave an extra .5 for being a Jacksonville Jaguars friendly bar/ pizzeria. Go Jags!!!!

Lots of grease, moderate amount of Davis Island flop, cheese is nice and chewy, sauce is pretty unnoticeable, crust is ok, seemed a bit on the side of too much flour in the dough. It’s ok pizza, I’m honestly trying to figure out why all the high scores everyone is giving. I can’t give this any more than a 6.2. The grease is just too much to make it any higher and the more I eat it the less I like it. This is ok drunk pizza, that’s a review.