Italia Pizza

Hard to find too much wrong with this place. Went with the Marg, the plain cheese and the square. All delicious. Got them as slices heated up, and it was great just getting slices that were cooked with good krisp, good char, crust and dough that had good flavor. Cheese was really good and sauce had a really nice hearty taste, but maybe just a bit too much sauce. If this was my neighborhood pizza spot, I’d rock it on the regular for sure and be happy about it.

Favorite pizza in North Jersey!

Very average-below average slice. Nothing terribly wrong but definitely nothing spectacular. Tad greasy, ingredients tasted a little cheap

Great pie, Portnoy should've reviewed this place after he reviewed Blue Steele, they're literally about 200 feet from each other. Cool owner, pretty sure he's from Italy.

Go to local pie, solid pie.

Pretty delicious pizza! Definitely the best in Bloomfield. Amazing balance and the sauce is absolutely mouth watering! Honestly surprising because the decor is kinda run down.

Happily surprised to declare... Best in Bloomfield! This delicious super-crispy (ok, burned) slice was probably sitting around a couple of hours, and was still terrific.

One of the best local slices I’ve had in Essex County, NJ. Well balanced flavor all around with a perfectly cooked crust. A large pie is $15 which is a little steep for the area, but it’s also better tasting than 95% of the pizza in the area. I’ll definitely be going back.

Under the radar spot. Small storefront in the center of town near a bunch of other stores. Real good slice. 8 flat.

Solid pizza.. wish it had more flavor but the crust was good.

For $16, this pie better DAZZLE! You know what? It does! The dough is very unique, it’s like a coal-fired zeppole. Tremendous texture & flavor. The sauce is sweet and just the right amount. The cheese is also excellent and spread perfectly. Aside from a little grease, this pizza is pretty fantastic all around. Truly a hidden gem in the town of Bloomfield and in the upper echelon of Jersey pizza.