Italian Deli and Market

Looked good. Was not. Lots of flop and cold in the center

Maybe a bit generous, but coming from Michigan, I’m starved for a good NY/NJ style slice. Decent cook. Crust a little crispy for me. Reminds me of a High quality NJ Boardwalk slice.

STOLEN A CONDOM FROM MY MOM OR DAD.

Good stuff

Cold lacks crisp

While on vacation in Marco Island, I looked to see who had good ratings, and they were there. 1. The place is very big with their own parking lot, just off the beaten path. 2. I've been to 2 other Italian market style places in the past, and they both were really good. This store has about 1/3 of the place dedicated to pizza. 3. I saw they use whole milk grande cheese, which is one of the best money can buy. It was a bit stringy to bite, but was totally fantastic. 4. The sauce was a very good tasting, home-made recipe, which they sell pre-portioned already, in the store. ( P.S. I looked at some past reviews here, and I see lots of oregano sprinkled on them. Mine was not like that, but if it was, I would not have appreciated as much!)

Solid can’t go wrong kinda pizza

Neapolitan style pie! Super thin, super floppy, sauce and cheese were fresh and overall it tasted awesome.

The New York pizza was just okay. The bottom was slightly undercooked and the ricotta was a bad call.

Good crunch on the crust decent undercarriage just didn’t have that nice crisp. Good sauce as well

Shoulda gotten cheese. Really solid

"Best New York Style Pizza in Florida" — could definitely be true, was a solid pie. They nailed the consistency on the crust/undercarriage (great crunch, zero flop). I like it a bit more burnt but that’s definitely too radical for down here.

Decent flavor. Too greasy which made the super this crust get soggy … but cheese and crust tasted good other then that solid pie I’d eat again

Hot out of the oven, best on Marco Island and great new location

Extremely crispy and burnt like the pres likes but I didnt. Taste was fair but all you can taste is sauce and cheese.

Down in Marco Island, Florida for a family wedding. The perfect cap to a weekend of drinking and beachin it? Sunday night pizza. This was definitely FOOTBALL pizza. I enjoyed it, I did. Though, the cheese didn’t knock my socks off and the sauce had flavor but nothing I’m gonna dream about before going to bed. The crust made me happy though. Crunchy and the slice had a good undercarriage. Add a friendly atmosphere with friends and family? You’re looking at a mid 6 score. It was delivery, in person could be high 6’s maybe even low 7’s if they’re having a good day. That’s a review.

Excellent pie, the BEST Marco has to offer! Amazing sauce, quality cheese and a solid undercarriage. If you’re on the Island the Italian Deli is a must try!

Nice thin, crispy crust with a sweet sauce

Marco Island, FL - Pizza by the slice Incredible crunch and flavor

What is going on here? Paper-thin crust was just molding to my hand. Hardly any sauce so I’m not sure what did it. It was definitely edible and the flavor was not awful. Maybe it’s the best Marco Island has to offer. If you’re starving after a day on the hot beach, it’ll hit the spot.

Lots of decent reviews but not sure what happened here. Half cheese half mushroom but the Pizza looked like a total mess. It was undercooked and the cheese was hard and sliding off the gum line. Was not as crispy as I had hoped. Flavor was decent and the pizza was light which were positives. I like a pizza that has fresh basil or oregano shook on it when it comes out of the oven which this one did. Could’ve used a little more sauce, little less cheese, and to be cooked longer.