ryan.rutherford1/16/21, 2:20 a.m.
That orange glow is emanating from a pie SOAKED in grease. This pizza is so oily, it completely overpowers the taste of the sauce. The cheese is an absolute oil slick, cascading down each slice out through the bottom of the crust. For all that greasiness, the dough is actually very firm, with a rather solid texture. The crust is outstanding, perfect crisp, excellent taste, carries the entire pizza. It’s a shame the other ingredients are overmatched by the abundance of grease. If you can stop the oil geyser, this pie could easily climb into the 8s. As it is, the crispy, crunchy, crust saves this pizza from dipping into the 6s.
roda11471/15/21, 6:29 a.m.
One of the best pies in the area. Above average some flop and grease but overall a good pie.... Better then josie's in Lyndhurst which Pres gave a high 7's I believe
matthew.divozzo12/8/20, 1:07 a.m.
Dave, gotta come to Italian Villa. The family who runs it are awesome dudes. I had a slice the other day, took a bite, not even off the crust and the crunch hurt my ear drums! Which is right up your alley. You have to give these guys a shot. Great pizza, great guys and gals
splitty6/19/20, 8:05 p.m.
Always a great slice from here. Good crisp, good sauce, and great flavor. I have never had a bad slice here. The owner is a great guy and I love stopping by. Worth a stop if in the area.
aogar1192/15/20, 4:00 a.m.
This pizza is the type of pizza that reminds me of back in the day. Still owned by Italians, generous with their cheese and great dough. I don’t mind eating from here when I’m in need for just a classic cheese pie at any time. Sauce is the only reason this isn’t rated in the 9’s for me. Wonderful and always consistent. Always my go-to pizzeria in the area.
rob.fagan9/21/19, 11:03 p.m.
If this is walking distance to your home, it’s a decent corner store slice. It’s not bad, just not anything to write home about. Nothing that makes you say I really want to go back to that place.
86 views•1 like
danielle.russo8/2/19, 1:05 a.m.
Crust is good and it’s a nice and salty slice. Sauce could be improved and a little less cheese.
ed.mckeown11/13/18, 11:59 p.m.
Flashback to High school... I think my pizza pallet is more refined now.