Very good slice. Nice crisp on the reheat. Not greasy and crust was perfect! Also had pepperoni slice. Cheese is the call here!
ryanloewy10/15/20, 5:10 p.m.
A really good standard slice Frank. Firm undercarriage, minimal flop, really good marinara and cheese. Wish there was more crust real estate, but overall real good football pizza. That’s a review Franklyn!!
jtpizza10/3/20, 5:39 p.m.
Needed a new pizzeria in the UES after a local favorite closed (fuck covid). I’d say Italian Village hits just what I was looking for. Could be a bit crispier in the bread and crust but I can live with it. Overall a solid slice that you can’t go wrong with in the UES.
jbo8/28/20, 1:14 a.m.
This slice is not an obvious winner. The presentation leaves more to be desired, but that first bite delivers. Cheese was more than good, and makes the slice, 8.7/10. The sauce isn’t perfect, but it is a perfect sidekick for the flavors, 7.3/10. The star is definitely the undercarriage and crust, absolutely perfectly crisp, and exactly what you need for this slice, 9.1/10. Overall, a great New York slice.
amordepizza2/21/20, 4:33 p.m.
Solid slice. Well done undercarriage. Little greasier than normal with the cheese but good sauce, a well done crust. Overall a good football slice.
pepperodni_slice2/15/20, 12:57 a.m.
Little salty but very tastey. Needs to pair with a Diet Coke
mrnewcanaan12/1/19, 6:56 p.m.
New location, same terrific slice. Quintessential NYC neighborhood slice joint.
moot6/2/19, 9:22 p.m.
Solid slice, prob one of the better ones in the area. Always a reliable consistency with them. Very cheesy.
coltan.severson2/2/19, 2:05 a.m.
I could possibly see how this was a 7.7 if I bought a slice at the place with a peroni and small Italian children ordering gelato. We got it delivered so if I were playing with a handicap score it’d be a 7.5, but I’m not, I’m taking one bite and giving it a score because I know the rules. 6.9.
saucy12/28/18, 6:13 p.m.
Alright Frankie, one bite everyone knows the rules, real deal NY pizza here, not much flop, pretty sweet tasting sauce, solid crunch..........