Italian Village Pizzeria

A very good pie. A tad greasy for my taste, but if I lived in the neighborhood I'd have this every day. More LI style than New Haven (thank god).

Very disappointed. Big flop, oily, no crunch at all, and the crust was doughy. The flavor was average.

Too much sausage for me on this, good pizza, great crust

They use good tasting cheese

Really greasy, pretty floppy because of that. Crust was good. Still a descent slice for a good price. Garlic knots were solid.

Forgot to take a pic at the place. Crust 9/10, sauce 8/10 but the cheese had a tang that was a bit bitter and also had a lot of cheese so it lowered the score.

Solid slice just took it out of the oven a little early

A flavorful slice with limited flop and good structure. A little on the greasier side, but still great quality and value. *Beef patty doesnt affect score*

Crust was crunchy and fluffy. Sauce had good tang.

This pizza was very good! Great crunch, good cheese and sauce, thick crust. Everything I like in a pizza!

Solid composition on this boy right here. Nice char on the undercarriage. Really nice ratio of cheese to crust. A bit of a sweetness to this one too. Doesn’t blow me out of the water, but very tasty. 🎤

This is some great pizza. The sauce is really good although the cheese leaves a little bit to be desired. Crust is elite. This slice wasn’t heated well enough. Could have been an 8.6.

A really good standard slice Frank. Firm undercarriage, minimal flop, really good marinara and cheese. Wish there was more crust real estate, but overall real good football pizza. That’s a review Franklyn!!

Very little crisp, good sauce, fairly thin, but pretty greasy

Excellent flavor, a bit of a greaseball, little to no crunch

Needed a new pizzeria in the UES after a local favorite closed (fuck covid). I’d say Italian Village hits just what I was looking for. Could be a bit crispier in the bread and crust but I can live with it. Overall a solid slice that you can’t go wrong with in the UES.

This slice is not an obvious winner. The presentation leaves more to be desired, but that first bite delivers. Cheese was more than good, and makes the slice, 8.7/10. The sauce isn’t perfect, but it is a perfect sidekick for the flavors, 7.3/10. The star is definitely the undercarriage and crust, absolutely perfectly crisp, and exactly what you need for this slice, 9.1/10. Overall, a great New York slice.

Great sauce, great crust. Classic ny pizza