Italianette Pizza

Sauce: The sauce was not bad. It wasn’t extremely flavorful but it wasn’t bland either. It was very average. Less sweet and more spiced which I prefer. Cheese: The cheese was average. There was a ton of grease though which has been my experience here before. I had to use a paper towel to get some of it off. However, the cheese had a good flavor surprisingly. Crust: I have to say the crust was absolutely tasteless. I’m not sure if it was just this one pie but it actually was one of the most bland tasting crusts I’ve had. The texture wasn’t bad but it tasted as if they just forgot to add any salt when they made it. Value: Great Value! This is where the score bumps up for me. My biggest pet peeve is an overpriced pizza. This pizza wasn’t the best but it is honest. It’s a cheaper neighborhood pizza that is doable and average tasting, and the price reflects that at only around $14 for a large pizza. Overall: Not a bad pizza, just not high quality or super flavorful but rather a cheaper neighborhood Pizza. I definitely could find myself back here sometime but I wouldn’t go out of my way.

Sauce bland, crust chewy and the cheese oily

Very good, one I will try to eat again

Solid pizza

Large Cheese Pie - $11.00 Great price for what you get. It’s very doughy with a ton of flavor. I’m not huge fan but not disappointed either. I knew the community score was way off just based on the videos. Tons of cheese that will melt your lips off. Sauce is good. Great football pizza

A little fluffier than typical bar pie. No flop, very little grease, and good ratio of ingredients, but nothing stood out to me. Undercarriage looked a tad undercooked for my preference. It’s good pizza, but to be honest I don’t understand all the super high scores.

One bite, everybody knows the rules. The crust is way thicker when you get family size, almost like Detroit style. Sauce is great, seasoning is great. If this had better cheese it would be a 9. Definitely in the top 5 Cincinnati pies.

Great crunch - unique sauce flavor

Pretty solid pizza. This is what we call in the business a “10-mile pizza”. If you live within 10 miles, give it a shot. Otherwise, you’re not missing much.

If it’s not the best pizza in Cincy, it’s damn close.

This is the BEST pizza in Cincinnati, fresh dough, fantastic sauce, the cheese is delicious and plentiful, nice crunch on the crust. This pizza is worth the drive and the score of 9.1!!! Go and try it for yourself