J & J's Pizza On The Square

Cool place. Local legend. Crust could use some crisp. Way way way too greasy. Too much flop. Tasty cheese and tasty sauce. But I know I’ll have acid reflux later. :( not sure I get the hype. I think it’s the location and vibe. Lots of band shows in the basement

Soft, floppy, lacking in taste.

Good pizza. Crust is too thick to be considered New York style. Also, got a lotta flop.

I’ve been eating here for 3 years and me and my girl love this place!

Do NOT get “NY style”... super doughy NOT crispy. Lott of flop. Just Average at Best and SUPER over priced...

Ok slice. Ok cheese ok sauce. A little better than frozen pizza

Big flop. Great crust. Needs a bit more flavor.

Great place cool vibe, great taste!

Flop for days, sauce is its saving grace.Very doughy too. $42 for a large pie, stuffed bread sticks, and two drinks. No thanks.

It’s alright, not as thin nor as large as NY style but still good

Lots of grease, lots of flop. Solid flavor

Flop, low-mid crisp, greasy. Cheese and sauce are good. Just not my kind of pie.

Alright guys. It was a doughy pizza, but the sauce made up for it. Good flavor and a good crunch on the crust.

Great pizza. One of the best in the area.

Very thin pizza but crust is very crispy, little oil on top of the pizza but not too drippy. Honestly the pizza is very basic. Kind of a flat taste to it. Football pizza all day every day. Not in love.