J & S Pizza

I saw they just put a fresh pie in the case, so I decided to go with slices instead of my usual whole pizza. I usually get a whole pizza to ensure I’m getting a fresh pizza. This pizza has been on my list for awhile and a baby shower near by finally led to me to trying this place. The cheese was good and the sauce was above average. It wasn’t good enough to get into the 8s. I was hoping to get a little more crisp in the undercarriage, but that wasn’t even close to being there. This place was good, but not necessarily worth traveling for. I’m glad I was already in the area for something else, because it wasn’t worth the 45 minute drive for.

Decent pizza. Buffalo chicken pizza was better than the pepperoni.

Messed up the last review

A perfect crunch

Good slice, pepperoni was delicious

🔥🔥🔥

Great thin pizza, light on the sauce. A little greasy but besides that one of the best pizzas I’ve had

Where do I begin? Perfect amount of crunch in the crust but the perfect amount of flop in the middle along with a great ratio of cheese to sauce. All of this combined with a great price and awesome service makes this place a slam dunk!

If I'm ever near the natrona heights, J & S is a must go to. The pizza is always good. I've traveled to alot of cities in the midwest and have eaten pizza throughout Pittsburgh and this is one of the best I've tried. The cheese and sauce are outstanding and consistently good every time I've been here. Crust has always been crispy but not super crispy like i love it. Not giving a higher rating even though it's the best pizza I've eaten because none of the cities I've visited seem to be known for pizza and i refuse to believe that the best pizza comes from a small town called natrona heights.

Alright Frankie. J and S pizza in Natrona Heights provided a solid pizza slice with little flop and low grease. The pepperoni was of high quality and the sauce to cheese ratio was up to par. Make sure you ask to have the crust cooked extra. Slightly better than football pizza.