Jimmy's New York Pizzeria

Best sliced pizza in Tulsa. New location is in Broken Arrow. Great undercarriage very light pizza not greasy.

Very good slice. Nice undercarriage, good sauce, no flop, 7.2 all day. Great football pizza!

Great crust and not a lot of flop. Good cheese to sauce ratio. One of the better slices in Tulsa.

A little greasey, it was crisp, had a good undercarriage. Solid pizza!

$5.95 huge meat slice. Good crisp.

Nice crisp. Good flavor. Could use a little more sauce and flavor at the crust. Good solid pizza!

Decent flop for a big slice, good cheese/sauce ratio. I found the crust a LITTLE doughy IMO. Good crisp in the undercarriage though. Sauce could use more of a tang. Good pizza

This is the best New York style pizza you will find in Tulsa hands down. Absolutely love that we found this place after moving here from NJ/PA.

This pizza could be great with better/less runny sauce. Crust is perfect. Fresh ingredients.

Excellent pizza excellent service

No taste, flop begins at the crust with a fold. Even the oregano doesn't have a taste.

Nice crisp. Large slice. Could use more sauce, but overall nice slice.

Bland, greasy, flavorless.....

Solid all round, good crust sauce is average

2 slices everyone knows the rules. Sauce lacks tang and crust needs more flavor. Overall not bad.

Good pizza

Good Pie. The crust is amazing. A bit greasy for my liking but a good football pie!