Jimmy's Pizza Café

For NY pizza in Chicago - I’d give it a 9.2 on the One Bite Scale. In NYC, I think they would still score high .. at least 8.4.

Best pepperoni on a slice in the city. Good cheese but kinda bland. Semi big flop but increasingly crispier crust on the way to a big crunch crust.

Alright, first off wow. Delicious. Fantastic crunch and minimal flop. The sauce needs some work.. it's a bit too sweet.. immediately thought of spaghetti-o's.. needs more kick & tang and spices. Crunch is perfect. Cheese is perfect. Ultimately, favorite pizza in this neighborhood so far.

Just ok pizza and nothing amazing. Many better places in Chicago. Toppings and sauce were good, but super dry crust. Huge portion size so it’s good value.

Margarita Slice- 8.3 🔥 Pepperoni Slice- 8.1 🍕 Figured I start off reviews strong with Jimmys. Well known for delicious NY style pizza in Chicago.

Not at all anything great. New York pizza is over rated and another example why.

Great slice. Hot and fresh and the crust is crispy.

Solid slice! Big flop and little greasy, but great flavor.

Great. NYC slice

Definitely the closet thing to an NY slice that I’ve had in Chicago. Very good and will be going back

Rookie score. They do it up right. Not much else to say.

Closest thing to NY style I’ve had n Chicago. Really floppy and could have been hotter, but great flavor.

Closest slice to NYC that I have had in 5 years living here. Very good slice! Crispy and no flop.

Good delicious pizza!

Salty cheese, good sauce/cheese/dough ratio. Deserves a bonus for coming in a wedge cut as standard in Chicago. They call it Neapolitan, but it is New York style, if anything.