dale.beggs7/3/19, 8:25 p.m.
Salty cheese, good sauce/cheese/dough ratio. Deserves a bonus for coming in a wedge cut as standard in Chicago. They call it Neapolitan, but it is New York style, if anything.
rynfel186/28/19, 8:51 p.m.
A little greasy, no flop. Better than Joe’s in New York. Very good pizza.
nathaniel.foengsang6/22/19, 12:55 a.m.
No flop, a bit greasy and the sauce is on the sweeter side. But one of the better spots in town.
idiots6/18/19, 5:06 a.m.
Best NY Style Pizza in Chicago. The owner puts a lot of care into his craft of making solid quality pizza.
harrison.paul5/26/19, 6:21 p.m.
Very solid crunch, cheese was a little greasy, could have used more sauce. Margherita sauce ratio was better but the sauce could use a bit more zest. Overall solid slice maybe best Nyc style in Chicago.
ryan.smith185/17/19, 5:38 p.m.
Like the other reviews. Good crunchy crust. Bland sauce. Sausage is definitely fresh and has good spicy flavor. Bonus review the Garlic bread is great (8.6).
johnhenry5/15/19, 4:34 p.m.
One bite ...etc... sauce is good not too sweet. Dough is cooked perfect. Cheese is artificial. Football pizza
steve.fremgen4/28/19, 8:49 p.m.
I agree with other reviews that Jimmys is better than most for NYC style in the Chicago area. Some flop, a bit of grease, great crunch and crust. That said, we would go back for more and next time order a whole pie and dine in.
jeremy.cervenka4/18/19, 12:50 a.m.
If you're not near New York this is about as good as it gets. 8.3 on the Midwest scale. 5.6 on the New York scale
pizzamd1/28/19, 6:49 p.m.
Moved to Chicago 6 months ago from NY and have been searching for a decent slice. Saw the Instagram and heard the hype so my wife and I made the 30 min drive to this place and ordered a pie. Even with the parm, oregano and pepper flakes this pizza was unbelievably bland. Sauce and cheese both have no flavor, and the pizza was cold even though we waited for a fresh pie. Was extremely doughy despite the photos I saw of thin, crispy looking slices. I know it’s Chicago and therefore I can’t expect a real NY slice, but I was really underwhelmed by this pizza. Sbarros makes a better pie.
mike.garrity112/24/18, 2:55 a.m.
Solid pizza. A bit lacking on the sauce but very evenly flavored
julian.akiva12/15/18, 12:22 a.m.
Best NY style in Chicago! Of course don’t expect a real NY slice. But classic slice! Great flavor! No NY flop though
38slugs11/30/18, 10:09 p.m.
This review is on the regular cheese slice: great sauce, crispy crust, a bit greasy but no New York flop. Solid! 8.3 The white pie slice: it was good but not my first choice. Had a real garlicky taste. The ricotta was tasty and creamy but again wouldn’t be my go to. 7.4
noah.gilbert11/24/18, 9:54 p.m.
Good basic pizza. There is crunch but there is something missing. 6.6