Jimmy's Pizza

This is a very unique, thick crust, personal pan pizza which I liked very much and I don't see too often in NY. It was everything I wanted and nothing i didn't. This wasn't a style I would normally go for, but I'll gladly come here again. Terrific!

First of all Jimmy is the man, his wife is so sweet and the other guy in there is great too. The pizza is a classic, perfect sauce to cheese ratio. Only reason this isn’t in the high 7’s even low 8’s is because it’s a little too floppy. Still a staple and I’m never disappointed. Jimmy is just a guy you want to keep around

Terrible. I don't know what you guys got, but the thing was soggy and floopy.

Jimmy’s is a Greek style pan pizza. Very crispy crust and delicious pizza. I highly recommend a visit, don’t get turned off by appearances, it’s something special.

PLACEHOLDER SCORE: 7.5 I stopped in at a slow hour and the slice I got was unique and good but I can't give a true score without trying a fresh pie. I've seen reviewers call this Greek style but it seems thinner, like a mix of NY style. Very intriguing. The unique look and taste combined with a beautiful undercarriage gives this slice at least a 7.5 but with a fresh pie, this could be a special pizza. I hope to return soon to possibly boost this score. I like the old man in this place, real authentic pizza man vibe.

The most amazing pizza you could ever have.

This is the best pizza!! Ask for it well done and you’ll be in heaven. It’s crispy with little flop. A pizza that el prez would be loving.

Greek style, cast iron pan cooked for an extra crispy crust. The sauce has a nice sweetness and just the right balance of cheese-to- sauce. Definitely top 3 in the county and the best in town. Stopped going to Sal's after discovering this little gem!

Greek style, Mamaroneck flop, thicc crust, good sauce and cheese