Joe & Pat's Pizzeria

Great pie with a NY style crust and sauce, but I don’t think it lives up to an 8.6 hype. That’s a monster score. I’ve tasted better 8.2’s — it’s a good pie don’t get me wrong. But 8.6? Nah… but still a stellar pie in Staten for a good price. Rookie score of 8 flat to balance out the scales on this one.

The bottle cap pepperoni is what makes their pie great. The slices are small, but compact. They are a legendary pizzeria. I gots to go 8.9

Really solid, wish it stayed hot for longer but maybe I dilly dallied

Joe and Pat’s is an S.I. staple, first time dining in and it did not disappoint. We had the Sicilian with meatball. Sauce, dough and cheese all worked so good together. The undercarriage was perfect reminds you a little of New Haven. The Sicilian is right up there with Brother’s and Tony’s as one of the best on S.I.

Really thin and crisp pizza with some soft spots that give complexity to its texture. This pizza tastes really fresh and light. Could use some more salt and some more flavor to the sauce, but the tomatoes are bright and have some tang.

Super thin, great sauce, top notch!

Very big sauce guy and their sauce was excellent. Pie on thinner side. Very enjoyable pie

Thin and crispy

Tri color pizza is one of the best I’ve ever had. Would recommend to a friend.

It's pretty average. The cheese is good and there's a pretty good amount of sauce. I'm not a huge fan of thin crust and there was a slight flop. But overall, I would recommend to at least try it.

Absolutely delicious. Thin, juicy, crisp, nice taste of grated parm on the sauce. Nice 70s disco vibes playing. Girls dancing. Great pizzeria.

Great sauce, great crisp. Could use a little more crust but regardless one of the best pies I’ve had in the island.

Outstanding bar pie!!!

Terrific pie. Not quite an 8.6 but very solid. Not a salt on pizza guy but the lady thinks it can use a dash of salt.

Regular with sausage. And Margarita. Both outstanding.

Cheese slice

Joe and pats is my favorite pizza in NYC. The sauce is amazing and crust is always perfect. I haven’t tried the Manhattan location but the original is top shelf.

Great pizza that could’ve been even better. There was something giving it a staleish taste Saucey saucey pie. Great cheese. Had the hint of parm which gave it a nice salty flavor. Not a greasy pie. Better crust without that stale flavor sends this pizza even higher.

No flop.

Sorry! Done fucked up. It is the best slice in SI! Accidentally gave it a 6.1 instead of the proper 8.9.