Joe's 58th St. Grill & Tavern

Boom or doom… Boom! BBQ Chicken Pizza one bite everyone knows the rules. Solid 7.7

If it were a good pizza oven or legit brick pizza id almost double my score. Rich flavor in the sauce, good cheese, nice little crunch to the end crust.

Lots of cheese here. Good flavor from sauce. No 58th Street flop. Standard football pizza.

Hear this one out... In standard Barstool rules, the standard cheese pizza is a 4.7. Nothing to write home about. However, the four cheese is a great 7.5. Not to mention the ranch four cheese combo is one of the best 1 2 combos in the area.

This pizza is a hit or a miss due to the drug addicts that run the kitchen but when it’s done right man it is done right!! Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. My only complaint is the crust which always seems to be undercooked.

Way too thin, rubbery, and not very good.

Bland crust. Sweet sauce. Very greasy. Geese perfectly melted. Crispy bacon.