Joe's Brooklyn Pizza

Hands down, the best pizza in Rochester

A great slice of pizza

Really disappointed given the high average score. Maybe I caught them on a bad day, but in an obvious attempt at a crunchy crust it ended up being DRY and over done. The 6.1 is generous since the sauce was good - I almost kept it in the 5.9 range.

The best pizza in Rochester!

The picture doesn’t do it justice. This is the only piece that made it home on my 10 minute drive back from Joe’s Brooklyn Pizza. Best pizza I’ve ever had in my life, no exaggeration.

crust is the right thickness. Not enough sauce. Cheese is good.

Solid NYC style pizza. In fact, better than some of the nonsense being passed off as pizza in NYC these days. The folks who run it are very cool. It’s the same team every time I go there which lends itself to consistency in the pizza. It’s a traditional slice shop with lots of variety. El Presidente should hit this place up next time he’s up for a Bills game or something.

Choose the Sicilian cheese for this review

Very good pizza. Great cheese sauce and pepperoni. You can tell when you walk In that everything is fresh. Smells great in there. Whoever cashed us out was very personal. Great experience all around and good pizza

Decent crisp, overall decent slice

Very good slice...

Huge flop; minimal ingredients. Very doughy. Every slice I’ve ever tried here. This is mediocre fucking pizza.

Very good crust. Cheese fall off and not too much flavor

That’s a review

Great crunch. No flop. Awesome sauce ... not too sweet. Best pie in Rochester hands down

The 100m Dash Slice. Crisp, no flop right outta the oven. Solid balance between sauce cheese and dough. Only missing a little somethin to be truly memorable.

Girlfriend brought this home so it was non-traditional: Pulled pork, bacon, ghost pepper flakes, well done with BBQ sauce. At first I thought it was odd, then after one bite that all changed. Powerful combo of flavor; if you’re into odd pizza, this is your jam.

Nice crunchy crust. Sause is great and great taste overall!